Onderwerp: »[V] MID Valuations

Omg, this is what i emailed the guy:

--- begin email ---
don`t wanna valuate those cuz they`re a bit weird...

Jolivet has no technique but vg striker? Can`t be a stri with that bad tech, and as a pm the tech is wasted... and def is too low to be that, i have no idea what position he`d be best in, and in any position he`s not as good as if tech wasn`t nonexistant.

Same with rivenet, and he`s old too so that makes it even tougher. he`s more of a defender tho, so at least i can see where he`d play lol. Mebbe 350k on him due to age.

--- end included email ---

*high5 vilpu :)

:)

which is the interest to send an email to me if you reposte it here ? :p

I explain, Rivenet is old but he is a former international. I think is a better DEF but in my team he play at MID. So I was mistaken, I post him in a bad thread.

For jolivet, I think he is a strange player but at defensive middlefield, he is quite good with his passing.
I know, they aren't a player for first league but both make around 40% at mid and he is enough good for little price no ?

And, in the rules, nothing prevents me that is prohibited to ask a valuation for a player without technique ;)

So, it is not worthwhile to send sk email to me, I can read it here ;)

thanks for your valuation.

well i sent it sk-mail first then wanted to show vilpu how similar our analyses were, plus as he already commented the same things i didn't think it'd hurt you to repeat it on the forum (i didn't want to say negative things about their skills publically until it was already out there)...

Of course you can ask for valuation if they meet the rules, my point was just that it was hard to valuate because you never know if some player is gonna ignore his age and oncoming skill drops when purchasing him, and we both estimated his value quite closely to eachother.

Next time if you prefer i'll just give a number without thought or justificatino :)

Sorry i don't speak english very well ^^ So, I badly expressed myself
I was not hurt. And I do not have wanted to seem insolate :)
I understood your point of considering without any problem.

I have may be the same point of view but I need to sell him and for a good price if it's possible ^^

thanks :)

ps : sorry for the mistaken :)
(gewijzigd)
(gewijzigd)

no worries, good luck on the sales. Both players can contribute to many teams out there, a 40 rating in the midfield can be a nice anchor for at least 2 years before he starts to degrade, and will still contribute after 3-4 most likely.

formidable stamina, hopeless keeper
excellent pace, very good defender
formidable technique, incredible playmaker
average passing, unsatisfactory striker

22 y/o

How much ?

$2.5m - $3m.

Get him some more passing and he could get to $3.5m - $4m....

Okei, thanks.

Karla Joala, age: 21
1029711

very good stamina, hopeless keeper
very good pace, good defender
excellent technique, good playmaker
very good passing, good striker

i know it's a tough question and maybe some of you will think he is a striker, anyway, how much?

anyone?

Sry hostaal i don't know. I have the same kind of player to ask his valuation.

Kris Martens, age 21
value: 319 250 €, wage: 3 000 €
divine form
bookings:

formidable stamina, tragic keeper
very good pace, solid defender
excellent technique, average playmaker
very good passing, solid striker

How much pls ?
greetz

1-2 M euros for both players

600-800k i think hes worth that

cheers mate, I'll train him some more til he easily breaks the 800k barrier :)

no wonder u beat me with players like that.. :.(